By @rpinho

AI for physics: certified bounds on published results, exact checks with independent referees, and bug reports on physics software

6dfea25 / friends/alho-signorini-and-pade/o004-signorini-balls/VERDICT.md

Raw
HOLDS
Referee: gpt-6.1-sol

I found no failure in the claimed existence theorem for every -1<nu<1/2
and every prescribed delta_c>1. The energy, pressures, gravity scaling,
and meaning of strongly regular ball match the primary papers.
The singular-center construction and compact first-exit argument survive
inspection; the positive-pressure denominator bound prevents premature
breakdown, and the virial inequality forces a finite surface.

I wrote independent code from the paper's energy and density equations,
importing no claimant code: 36 exact symbolic checks passed, including
epsilon=1/136 and R_s^2<=7650 at nu=1/4, delta_c=8.
Four baseline runs reproduced R_s=1.232623252189 and 1.077019682654.
These are computed dimensionless radii, not numbers tabulated in Figure 8;
unit conversion gives approximately 0.6023 and 0.5262, consistent with its plots.
The plot's unit convention is inferred; the physical scaling is exact.
Forty-two stress cases and no-gravity controls were also run on mscr.
One coarse numerical negative-pressure flag disappeared under tighter and
70-digit replay; the original flag and all evidence are retained locally.

There is no dataset or hold-out; Figure 8 is public calibration data.
Both papers identify Artur Alho (Instituto Superior Tecnico) as an author.
Relative to [the 2021 paper, question (a)](https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.11131v2),
the addition is an all-parameter analytic proof and loose radius bound;
the existence behavior was already supported numerically there.
Beig-Schmidt's earlier small-body theorem and a 2019 Alho talk mentioning
Signorini existence remain relevant prior facts. Search coverage is incomplete;
PRIOR_ART.md records access gaps without adjudicating priority or taste.

Strongest objection: exact algebra and shooting alone cannot certify the
singular center or global continuation. I checked those analytic hypotheses
by hand and supplied an independent center integral formulation in ANALYSIS.md;
this remains a mathematical review, not a machine-formalized theorem.

NEXT BAR: turn that center integral formulation into a self-contained
local-existence lemma with explicit contraction hypotheses in the manuscript.