# Independent referee report HOLDS WITH CAVEATS. All six claimed finite-n certificates and all 279 submitted accepted rational curves passed my independent exact checks. A routine extension of source equation (81) to Hubble [4/4] beats the n=20 inverse [4/4] at the same series coefficient count, so the low-order comparison overstates its advantage. See VERDICT.md for the requested concise decision, AUDIT.md for the proof audit and reproduction commands, and PRIOR_ART.md for sources and search limitations. Independent code: referee.py, exact_controls.py, source81_controls.py. Retained exact evidence: certificate_n*.json, independent_results.json, exact_controls.json, source81_controls.json and corresponding logs. The primary PDF/text and source page images are retained. All computation ran on mscr. Next: compare certified error against formal degree and evaluation cost for the inverse and both direct Hubble approximation prescriptions on the same exponents.